Sidney Joe's

Discover Sidney Joe's Pizza at 59 Main St, Sidney, NY, offering delicious calzones, garlic knots, subs, chicken tender subs, and Philly cheesesteak pizza. Family-owned with generous servings and flavorful stromboli. Call +1 607-563-8368!

View MenuContact

Welcome to Sidney Joe's

Experience the finest dining

Sidney Joe's
Sidney Joe's
Sidney Joe's
Sidney Joe's

Sidney Joe's Pizza stands out on Main Street in Sidney, NY, as a local favorite. This family-owned gem specializes in hearty portions and mouth-watering flavors that satisfy all cravings. From calzones to garlic knots and succulent subs, each dish delivers a taste of culinary perfection. One can't miss the renowned Philly Cheesesteak Pizza, a creative twist that captures the essence of two beloved classics. Expect a warm, inviting atmosphere that encourages every diner to feel at home.

Whether you're grabbing dinner for the family or enjoying a night out with friends, Sidney Joe's welcomes all with open arms. Make sure to stop by or call for takeout at +1 607-563-8368 and experience what locals rave about!

Sidney Joe's offers a diverse menu that caters to every taste bud, featuring 65 plates packed with rich flavors. Menu highlights include hearty appetizers such as mozzarella sticks and onion rings, perfect for sharing or indulging solo. For those seeking refreshing options, a variety of fresh salads adds a healthy twist to the dining experience. The specialty pizza section showcases pies that elevate the traditional pizza experience, while dinners like stuffed shells and eggplant parmesan promise to fill even the hungriest diners.

The sub options, both cold and hot, offer choices that please everyone in the family. With an average price point of just $10.94, Sidney Joe's provides delicious meals that are budget-friendly. The generous servings leave diners satisfied and returning for more.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

59 Main St, Sidney, NY 13838, United States

Phone

+1 607-563-8368

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Sidney Joe's
Sidney Joe's
Sidney Joe's
Sidney Joe's

Sidney Joe's Pizza has become a staple in the Sidney community since its inception. With its roots firmly planted in the region, this family-run restaurant prides itself on creating not just food, but a warm environment conducive to gathering. Sid's food philosophy revolves around generous servings, ensuring nobody leaves hungry. Each dish, from the calzones to the garlic topping, reflects the owners' commitment to quality and tastes that bring people together. Popular choices like the chicken tender sub and Philly Cheesesteak Pizza demonstrate how Sid's crafts traditional recipes with a personal touch.

With a history of excellence and community focus, diner experiences at Sidney Joe's extend beyond the plate; they foster connections among friends and families who share meals together.

Throughout the week, peak times bring the community buzzing through its doors. Fridays typically see the restaurant at 100% capacity by 5 PM, showing just how beloved this establishment is for Friday night dinners. For those looking to avoid the crowd, a visit during the quieter Monday mornings offers a peaceful atmosphere to enjoy breakfast and coffee.

With simple decor complementing the upbeat vibe, Sidney Joe's serves as a cheerful gathering spot for residents and visitors alike. Whether you're a local or just passing through, experiencing the unique charm and flavors of Sidney Joe's is a must.

Sidney Joe's

The exterior of Sidney Joe's feels inviting, with its classic signage and warm lighting welcoming guests. Located at 59 Main St, the restaurant fits right into the charming downtown of Sidney, perfect for a quick stop or a leisurely meal. Outdoor seating options provide guests a chance to enjoy warm evenings while devouring their favorite pizza or subs.

The overall vibe maintains a laid-back atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for families and friends to connect over delicious food. Locals often gather here, sharing stories and laughter as they indulge in Sidney Joe's culinary delights.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • Monday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Friday10:30 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday10:30 AM-9 PM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

You're craving a real Italian pizza then come to Joe's because they do not disappoint. I had a very simple white sauce cheese pizza and topped with garlic absolutely to die for. Not to mention the people that work here are super nice. Can eat in there's a dining room in the back sometimes there's a waitress sometimes there's not no big deal The pie is worth it all.

B
Bree G.

To the 3 young man working up front at the counter today around 1:30 -1: 40 pm You 3 where doing a great job. Great communication,, working well with each other , calm. Great flow doing your guys thing. Wasn't sure why someone else had to come in and upset your guys flow. . THANK YOU GENTLEMAN FOR LUNCH, enjoy your guys work atmosphere as we waited . Keep up the great work.

K
Kimberly W.

The pizza was decent but the service was above and beyond for the fact that they did not have any servers on staff.

J
Jessica J.

Huge Calzone! Delicious, and exactly what I wanted. I have leftovers - more than enough for 2 meals.

M
Marsha K.

As a lifetime resident of Sidney, Joe's Pizzeria (formerly Joe and Vinny's) is THE place to go for pizza. There have always been many options in Sidney for pizza, but no one does New York style pizza like Joe's. They also have delicious subs, salads, and hot dinners, and their wings are meaty, crispy, and the house-made sauce is so good. The staff is friendly and helpful. If there is ever any issue with an order, it is promptly fixed. They go above and beyond for their customers. Five stars all around. This family owned restaurant has made a lifer out of me!

M
Madison B.

Family owned pizza place with cheap delicious pizza. They have a large seating area in the back too so it's not just takeout. Best pizza in the area in my opinion.

C
Christopher Y.